“God out of His goodness gave us holy
instructions which, if we keep them, can purify us of our sins and
also from those tendencies which lead us to evil. Sin is one thing,
but passion is another. These are our passions: pride, anger, sexual
indulgence, hate, greed, and so on. Sin occurs when we gratify these
passions by bringing them into reality through our actions”
(ibid.).
Saint John Climacus explains that
“passion was not planted by God in nature, for He is not the
Creator of passions . . . God is not the cause of evil. Those who
teach that passions are natural to the soul are wrong, not realizing
that it is we who have turned natural things into passions. For
example, by nature we have within us the seed necessary for
childbearing; but we have perverted this into fornication. Nature
gave us the feeling of anger, which we are supposed to use against
the Evil One; instead we use it against our neighbor . . . We have
been given a longing for pleasure; but we use it for dissipation”
(The Ladder of Divine Ascent). Passion, then, is an
exaggeration or perversion of something natural to fallen human
nature.
“Pleasure and pain, and the desire
and fear that accompany them, were not originally created together
with human nature [that is, before the fall of man] . . . According
to the teaching of the great Gregory of Nyssa, they were introduced
after our being had lost the inherent perfection of its nature,
having been grafted upon that part of us which is the least rational.
It is through these [pleasure and pain] that, immediately after the
transgression of the commandment, our likeness to dumb animals,
instead of to the blessed image of God, became visibly and clearly
manifest in us” (St. Maximus the Confessor, Contemplations and
Active Texts).
In other words, at the time of the fall
of man, the rational, knowing, discerning part of our nature became
darkened; we began to be motivated by an irrational, animal-like
desire for pleasure and avoidance of pain, rather than by a rational
love for God.
Therefore, “we who wish to achieve
the life of Christianity with any great thoroughness must, before
anything else, cultivate with all our might that part of the soul
which discerns and discriminates. In this way we will acquire a
delicate sense of the difference between good and evil . . . By using
the power of discernment as a kind of eye, we may keep free from any
union with the suggestions of sin. Thus the heavenly gift may be
vouchsafed to us by which we become worthy of the Lord . . . .
“The body has the eye for its guide.
The eye, by seeing, guides the whole body straight . . . It is his
light, to save him from stumbling down the cliffs, or getting drowned
in the waters, or injured by some other danger . . . But if a man is
idle, and slothful, and careless, and clumsy, and slack . . . and if
he does not attend properly and well to what his eye tells him, he
will himself fall into some ravine, or be drowned in the waters.
“In the same way the soul, which is
clothed in the fair garment of the body for its vesture, possesses
the faculty of discernment to direct the whole soul, together with
the body, as it passes amidst the thickets and thorns of life, and
the mud, and the fire, and the precipes, which are the lusts and
pleasures and other wrong things of this world. It ought to wrap
itself . . . closely in on every side with vigilance, and resolution,
and heed . . .
“But if a man goes his way in this
life with slackness and carelessness . . . and, to please himself,
will not turn away from all the lust of the world, and will not seek
the Lord, and Him alone . . . he is pierced on the thorns and
thickets of this world, and the garment of the body is burned by the
fire [of passions]” (St. Macarius the Great, Homily 41).
“We can cultivate the ability to
discern right and wrong if we understand the three movements which
lead to passion:
1. “The first is a natural movement,
inherent in the body, which does not produce anything sinful or
burdening to the conscience, but merely lets it be known that it
exists in the body” - such as hunger.
2. “The second kind of movement in
the body is produced by too much food and drink, which stimulates the
body to fight against the soul,” urging it towards sin.
3. “The third movement comes from
evil spirits who, because they are envious, try to tempt and weaken
us . . . leading us astray” (St. Anthony the Great, Directions
on Life in Christ).
Here we see that the natural appetite
of the body innocently expresses itself: feeling the pangs of hunger,
we prepare food and eat to fullness. Suddenly certain thoughts come
to us involuntarily. Until “our will consents, these thoughts
constitute neither virtue nor vice, but merely disclose the
inclination of our will” (St. Mark the Ascetic, Epistle to the Monk
Nicholas). This thought is: I will eat more than is needful.
If we act upon this thought by eating
more, passion is born.
“Suppose a thought of love of money
has been suggested to you. Separate it by analysis: 1. the thought of
gold, 2. gold itself, 3. and the money-loving passion [greed].
Finally ask: Which of these is the sin? Is it the mind? But how can
that be, since it is the image of God? Is it the thought of gold
then? But what man who has a mind can even say that? Is gold itself
sinful a sin? But then, why was it created? Thus, it remains the
passion itself, which is neither a concrete, independent thing . . .
but an inhuman lust, born of free will and urging the mind to misuse
God's creations” (Abba Evagrius, On Various Evil Thoughts).
Once our willpower weakens and we begin
to indulge a passionate deed (whether a deed of the mind or the
body), then evil spirits seize upon our lack of vigilance and suggest
to us even greater sins.
“All thoughts coming from demons
introduce into the soul sensory objects, and the mind turns them over
in itself. So we can learn from this which demon has approached us.
For instance, if an image of someone who has done me harm or who has
insulted me comes into my mind, it shows me that the demon of
resentment has drawn near . . . I do not mean that all memories of
such things come from demons, . . . but only those things that
unnaturally evoke excitation or desires” (Abba Evagrius, On
Various Evil Thoughts). This is why St. John of Damascus says
that “passion is a movement against nature,” immoderate and
intense (On the Orthodox Faith).
“If we deliberately . . . give
ourselves over either to eating or drinking beyond measure . . . then
we replace the body's naturally gentle movement by one that is
violent and unbridled.
“All that God has created, He created
most beautifully and harmoniously. And as long as this degree of
harmony with what we are by nature is preserved in us, natural
movements cannot force us to stray from the path. Only harmonious
movements arise in our body, which merely informs us of the existence
of a natural passion, but produce no excitement or turmoil so strong
as to interfere . . . Attacks come from our laziness and excessive
indulgence of the flesh . . . When the body is kept within bounds,
thoughts cannot indulge in dangerous flights” (St. Isaac of Syria,
Directions in Spiritual Training).
- From The Teaching of the Holy Fathers on the Passions.
Nikodemus Orthodox Publication Society, Richfield Springs, NY, 2002.